Only a Game

"Hah," She thought, "Here shall be a new game."

Wikipedia Knows Nothing

Wikipedia Knows Nothing.v2-blackWhat does the Wikipedia know, and how can it know it? More to the point, how can anyone using an anonymously edited source, the contents of which change on a daily basis, know that what they are reading constitutes knowledge? In this provocative challenge to contemporary concepts of objectivity, four figures of knowledge – the Wikipedia, scientific experiments, anonymous peer review, and school education – are investigated in order to question the way we understand the world around us.

Rather than support the classical view of an objective world 'out there' that our beliefs must accord with in order to count as knowledge, Wikipedia Knows Nothing argues that all facts are the residue of skilled activities and that knowledge is better understood as a practice. Furthermore, rather than a single 'real world', the many worlds that we each live within form a multiverse about which our subjective knowledge-practices give us broader understandings than the objective knowledge produced by experimental apparatus.

The merit of the sciences doesn't lie in their possessing the only path to truth, but in their capacity to develop knowledge-practices that can resist objections across all worlds. This leads to an urgent need to recognise the role of practices in creating and maintaining knowledge, and the different ways that truth can be stitched together into distinct but non-contradictory patchworks of 'real worlds'. When we do, we must question any claim that knowledge can come from anonymous individuals exercising an unchecked power to silence others – whether this happens on the internet in wikis, or in professional academic discourse.

Out now from ETC Press. Purchase Print or eBook from Lulu.com, Kindle version from Amazon.com or .co.uk, or Download PDF for free! This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-No Derivative Works 2.5 License. 

Please join me at Substack!


  • Enjoy Chris' philosophical essays? Have a 3-minute reflection on our principles for life emailed to you every week with Stranger Worlds and How To Live in Them

Search

Get posts by email
Powered by follow.it
Follow @SpiralChris
My Photo

About

  • Read my 'Wikipedia in Exile' Entry

  • Michael Moorcock
    "a genuine philosophy for the 21st century"
  • Mary Midgley
    "this matters - read it!"
  • Kendall Walton
    "wonderfully refreshing and inventive"

Recent Comments

  • Matt on The Activist's Argument (Everything is Political)
  • Chris on Post Mortem: Ghost Master (Part One)
  • Antonia on Post Mortem: Ghost Master (Part One)
  • Chris on The Power of Words
  • jerry barclay on The Power of Words
  • Chris on Trouble Commenting?
  • Irina on Trouble Commenting?
  • Chris on An Abundance of Useful Idiots
  • .. on An Abundance of Useful Idiots
  • Chris on Post Mortem: Ghost Master (Part Two)

Recent Posts

  • The Ten Player Motives
  • The Last Citizens
  • Our Duty to the Truth
  • Changing the Game
  • November on WAMTNG
  • Sabbatical
  • October on WAMTNG
  • Origins of Ghost Master, Part One
  • Beyond Victory (Game Days 2022)
  • Open Data

Out Now!


  • Revised and Expanded!
    A brand new edition of the original Game Writing how-to guide available now as paperback, hardback, and ebook
  • Evan Skolnick
    "Comprehensive coverage of writing for games. Other books have been published since the first edition came out, but none have surpassed it."

Are You A Good Cyborg...?


  • Jane McGonigal
    "immerse yourself in the strange new dilemmas of the future with this wonderful, mind-bending book"
  • Michaël Samyn, Tale of Tales
    "Cyberspace is as good a place as any to start finding our way back to who we really are, and to who we can be"
  • Babette Babich
    "a fresh and vigorous philosophical voice"
  • Justin Robertson
    "casts a critical but optimistic eye on the important choices we must make"

How do you 'know'?


Zero Books Trilogy




Sci-fi Fan...? TNG Fan...?


  • Join me over at Substack for WAMTNG - boldly going where we've all been before... only slightly differently!

Foreword

  • A Brief Introduction to My Philosophy
  • Player's Handbook
  • Trouble Commenting?

How Can Humanity Reach the Tenth Millennium...?

  • 1. The Tenth Millennium
    Imagining the future: Frank Herbert's Dune versus Isaac Asimov's Foundation
  • 2. Assembling the Future
    Memory of the past, knowledge of the future. Assembling a plurality of reciprocal collectives.
  • 3. Sustaining the Present
    Rejecting accelerating technology. Neutral population growth without abandoning families.
  • 4. Restoring the Commons
    Securing solidarity by eliminating poverty. New commons to aid in the subsistence of all.
  • 5. The Ascenturian Collectives
    Who are the Ascenturians? Can they open a path for humanity to survive until the Tenth Millennium?

Republic of Bloggers

  • Beyond Space
  • Wisdom in Practice
  • The Game of Art
  • Knowing That We Know
  • The Politeness of Tutorials (Japanese vs. Western Game Design)
  • Horror and Punishment (Silent Hill 2)
  • The Merit of Letters
  • Latour contra Badiou
  • The Echoes of Genre
  • Expertise as Involvement
  • The Dragon of Chaos
  • The Value of Art
  • The Rules of Game Worlds
  • Games, Guns, and Gender
  • Taxation as Injustice
  • Prelude: Virtuous Discourse
  • What is the Republic of Bloggers?

My Blogs

  • Only a Game (Philosophy)
  • ihobo (Games and Game Design)
  • Shadowtail (Squirrels!)

Game Design




Science Fiction & Fantasy

  • A Study in Psylocke
  • Corporate Megatexts
  • Exterminate! The Dalek and the Drone Assassin
  • Fifty Differences Between The Desolation of Smaug and Tolkien's Work
  • Faithful Adaptation and The Hobbit
  • Cyberpunk is Dead
  • Moorcock on Fiction (Interview)
  • Orthodox Science Fiction
  • Religion in Science Fiction
  • Moorcock's Metaphysics

Philosophy of Science

  • Magical Science
  • What is Pseudoscience?
  • Reiss Against Adaptation (Interview)
  • Midgley on Philosophy (Interview)
  • Myths of Evolution
  • Science vs Creationism
  • Ethics of Science
  • The Mythology of Science
  • Genes and Behaviour
  • Trust in Science
  • Teleological Games
  • The Boundary of Science
  • Cognitive Dissonance
  • Popper's Milestone
  • Skeptics
  • Farewell to Reason

Political Philosophy

  • The Seduction of Facts
  • No-one is Independent
  • Creedism
  • The Activist's Argument (Everything is Political)
  • Freedom of Belief
  • Global Population
  • Ethics of War
  • Civil Disobedience
  • The Prime Directive
  • The Mandate of Heaven (Political Legitimacy)
  • Hannah Arendt's "The Human Condition"

Philosophy: Fictionalism

  • Mimesis as Make-Believe (Serial)
  • Game Design as Make-Believe (Serial)
  • Walton on Make-Believe (Interview)
  • Pluto and Eris - a dialogue
  • The Authorized Stories
  • Yablo on Fictionalism (Interview)

Philosophy: Epistemology

  • Why the Wikipedia Knows Nothing
  • Knowledge as a Practice
  • Knowing That We Know
  • The Subjective Knowledge of Squirrels

Philosophy of Mind

  • Voiding The Hard Problem of Consciousness
  • Is Free Will Too Cheap?

Philosophy: Ethics

  • Allen Wood on Ethics (Interview)
  • Getting Wasted (A Moral Question)
  • The Ultimate Moral Computer?
  • Alain Badiou's Truth
  • A Categorical Imperative for the Other
  • Midgley on Philosophy (Interview)
  • Enemy: A Morality Tale (Pentenary Special)
  • Joanna Zylinska on Bioethics (Interview)
  • Abortion vs Suicide
  • Freedom of Belief
  • Future Ethics (Consequentialism)
  • Ethics of Metaphysics
  • Kant's Yardstick
  • Tit for Tat (Selfishness)
  • Duty, Virtue and Consequences
  • The Golden Rule
  • Relative Ethics
  • Preface

Philosophy: Metaphysics

  • Introduction
  • Popper's Milestone
  • Marxism
  • A Deck of Realities
  • Fate
  • Ethics of Metaphysics
  • Rumours of God's Death
  • Absurd Doubts
  • Immortality
  • Kant's Critique of Judgement
  • Midgley on Philosophy (Interview)
  • Immortality Stories

Philosophy of Language

  • Language Games
  • This is Not a Tomato
  • The Power of Words (Hypnosis)
  • The Stories We Tell

Idealistic Themes

  • Bucky's Big Idea (a Global Energy Network)
  • Mutual Respect & Communal Autonomy (Kant's Ethics)
  • Freedom of Belief

Temperament

  • Preamble: The Human Operating System
  • Introduction to Temperament Theory
  • Justifications and Criticisms
  • Statistical Disclaimer
  • 1. Rational
  • 2. Guardian
  • 3. Artisan
  • 4. Idealist

Religion/Non-religion

  • Ontology as Non-Theology
  • Haught on Theology (Interview)
  • Immortality Stories
  • Science and the Sacred
  • Creedism
  • Religion in Science Fiction
  • Islamophobia!
  • Charles Taylor's "A Secular Age"
  • Don't Talk About Creationism, Or Else
  • Christianity & Contraception
  • Hemp: The Illegal Sacrament
  • God's Dice
  • The Meaning of Life
  • Kierkegaard's "Fear and Trembling"
  • Pascal's Wager & the Agnostic's Lemma
  • The Religious Cold War
  • Sufi
  • Einstein & God

Rambling Nonsense

  • The Science Pope?
  • Don't Believe in Cthulhu
  • Reality, Optional
  • Considering Politics
  • Thought for Food

Other Curiosities

  • Agent Swarm
  • Agoners
  • All Ontologies Blazing
  • Always Curious
  • Angie Hobbs' Blog
  • Casual Game Design
  • Collision Detection
  • Cult of The Turtle
  • Curiouser and curiouser!
  • Design Synthesis
  • Dragonsfoot
  • Feet of Clay
  • First Person Scholar
  • Future Of Videogames
  • Retro Remakes
  • Game Bias (Jed Pressgrove)
  • Game Girl Advance
  • Game of Design
  • Game Ontology Project
  • GameProducer.Net
  • Games * Design * Art * Culture
  • Gausswerks
  • Ghosts in the Game
  • Grumpy Gamer
  • IEEE Task Force on Player Satisfaction Modeling
  • Industry Broadcast
  • Jay is
  • Jeroen D Stout's Tumblr
  • Journals of Doc Surge
  • King Lud IC
  • LCAD Art of Game Design MFA
  • Lost Garden
  • Ludus Novus
  • Man Bytes Blog
  • Monica’s Mind
  • Nature is not a Book
  • Neil Gaiman's Journal
  • Nongames.com
  • Notes on Game Dev
  • Omnivangelist
  • Out There
  • Philosophy and Life
  • Philosophy of Religion
  • Postcards From The Uncanny Valley
  • Purse Lip Square Jaw
  • Raph’s Website
  • Raven's Nest
  • Repeater Books
  • Science In Crisis
  • Science is a method, not a position
  • Science Pope
  • SIG: Cheap Speech
  • SIG: Christy Marx
  • SIG: Coray Seifert
  • SIG: Garbage Dump
  • SIG: Mildly Diverting
  • SIG: Red Flag
  • SIG: Richard Dansky
  • SIG: Subversified
  • SIG: Writing & Design
  • Sinistre and Destre’s noumenal realm
  • Slam
  • Snarkmarket
  • Sub Specie (Oscar Strik)
  • SubGamers
  • Susan Olmetti (Abstract Artist)
  • Synthetic Zero
  • Tea Leaves
  • Terra Nova
  • The Artful Gamer
  • The Designer's Notebook
  • The Dust Forms Words
  • The Kryptonite Cafe
  • The Lotus Window
  • The Thoughts of Chairman Bill
  • The World-Cave
  • Tiny Subversions
  • Top Of Cool
  • Wonderland
  • zenBen's Land of Words
  • Zero Books

Categories

  • Book Review (14)
  • Cybervirtues (147)
  • Dialogues/Interviews (51)
  • Doctor Multiverse (5)
  • Ethics (139)
  • Farewells (9)
  • Fictionalism (37)
  • Game Design (116)
  • Game Philosophy (55)
  • Game Projects (55)
  • Game Research (73)
  • Game Writing (50)
  • Games (293)
  • Guest Posts (7)
  • Interrupt (61)
  • Miscellany (50)
  • Only a Game (134)
  • Personal (11)
  • Philosophy (234)
  • Political Philosophy (83)
  • Polls (30)
  • Reflections (57)
  • Religion/Non-religion (102)
  • Republic of Bloggers (59)
  • Science Fiction/Fantasy (59)
  • Sciences (84)
  • Snippets (39)
  • Speaking Gigs (5)
  • Tabletop Games (20)
  • WAMTNG (7)
  • Wildlife (14)
  • Writing/Books (42)
See More

Archives

  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • September 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022

More...

Blog powered by Typepad
  • Only a Game •
  • Powered by Typepad
Top